Minimum Viable Utility (MVU), a core concept in Lean Startup methodology, requires a practical application. This is where an MVU calculation example becomes crucial. Understanding the input parameters needed for these calculations often involves software tools or platforms, such as Jira, and is a key skill set that product managers aim to develop. The article presented here focuses on mvu calculation example, a method for determining a baseline of functionality required for a viable product.
Homebrewing, at its heart, is an act of creation. It’s the transformation of humble ingredients – water, grain, hops, and yeast – into something far more complex and satisfying: beer. Beyond the simple act of brewing, it offers a unique opportunity to personalize your consumption experience, exercise control over the ingredients you use, and tap into a world of flavor experimentation.
From crafting a simple pale ale in your kitchen to meticulously replicating a complex Belgian Dubbel, the world of homebrewing offers a diverse range of challenges and rewards. Whether you’re a novice or plan to become a seasoned pro, there is always something new to learn and refine.
The Allure of Personalized Beer
The greatest draw of homebrewing is arguably the ability to craft a beer that perfectly suits your taste. Tired of the limited selection at your local store? Want to tweak the bitterness, aroma, or body of your favorite brew? Homebrewing puts the power in your hands.
Imagine a crisp, refreshing IPA brewed with your favorite blend of hops, or a dark, rich stout infused with the flavors of coffee and chocolate. Homebrewing empowers you to bring these visions to life, creating beers that are truly one-of-a-kind.
Cost-Effective Quality
While the initial investment in equipment might seem daunting, homebrewing can actually be a cost-effective way to enjoy high-quality beer. Once you have your basic setup, the cost per bottle is significantly lower than purchasing comparable craft beers from a store.
Moreover, you have complete control over the quality of ingredients. You can opt for organic grains, locally sourced hops, and carefully selected yeast strains, ensuring that your beer is made with the best possible materials. The ability to both save money and elevate quality makes homebrewing an appealing option for the discerning beer enthusiast.
Joining the Homebrewing Community
Homebrewing is more than just a solo endeavor; it’s a gateway to a vibrant and supportive community. From local homebrewing clubs to online forums and social media groups, there are countless opportunities to connect with fellow brewers, share recipes, exchange tips, and learn from each other’s experiences.
These communities provide invaluable support for beginners, offering a wealth of knowledge and encouragement. Don’t hesitate to ask questions, share your successes (and failures), and participate in local events. The camaraderie and shared passion within the homebrewing community are invaluable assets for any aspiring brewer.
A Word of Caution: The Learning Curve
While homebrewing is a rewarding hobby, it’s important to approach it with realistic expectations. There is a learning curve involved, and you’re likely to encounter a few bumps along the way. Don’t be discouraged by initial mistakes or setbacks.
Off-flavors, stalled fermentations, and other unexpected issues are all part of the learning process. The key is to be patient, meticulous, and willing to learn from your errors. Embrace the challenges, view them as opportunities for growth, and remember that even experienced brewers occasionally encounter problems. With perseverance and a willingness to learn, you’ll be well on your way to mastering the art of homebrewing.
Homebrewing empowers you to bring these visions to life, creating beers that are truly one-of-a-kind.
While the initial investment in equipment might seem daunting, homebrewing can actually be a cost-effective way to enjoy high-quality beer. Once you have your basic setup, the cost per bottle is significantly lower than purchasing comparable craft beers from a store.
Moreover, you have complete control over the entire brewing process. That journey begins with assembling the necessary tools to turn your brewing dreams into a reality.
Essential Equipment: Setting Up Your Home Brewery
Embarking on your homebrewing adventure requires a foundational set of equipment. This initial investment allows you to control the brewing process from start to finish.
This section details the essential items you’ll need, explaining their function and offering advice on balancing quality and affordability. We’ll also explore the advantages of starter kits versus purchasing individual components.
Primary Fermentation Vessel: The Heart of Your Brew
The primary fermentation vessel is where the magic happens. This is where yeast transforms sugary wort into beer.
You have two main choices: buckets and carboys.
Buckets are generally made of food-grade plastic. They are a popular choice for beginners due to their durability, ease of cleaning, and relatively low cost. Look for buckets specifically designed for brewing, as these are made from materials that won’t impart unwanted flavors to your beer.
Carboys are typically made of glass or PET plastic (polyethylene terephthalate). Glass carboys are impermeable to oxygen. This is an advantage for long-term aging, but they are heavier and more fragile than plastic options. PET plastic carboys offer a good compromise, providing oxygen resistance with greater durability.
Regardless of your choice, ensure the vessel is appropriately sized for your batch volume. A five-gallon batch typically requires a 6.5-gallon fermenter to allow for krausen (the foamy head that forms during fermentation).
Airlock: Guarding Against Oxidation
The airlock is a crucial component that attaches to your fermentation vessel. It allows CO2 produced during fermentation to escape. Crucially, it prevents outside air and contaminants from entering.
This is vital because oxygen exposure after fermentation can lead to oxidation, resulting in stale or cardboard-like off-flavors in your beer.
Airlocks come in two primary designs:
-
S-shaped airlocks: These are simple and inexpensive.
-
Three-piece airlocks: These are easier to clean and less prone to "suck back" (where liquid is drawn back into the fermenter).
Both types are effective when properly filled with sanitizer solution. Regularly check the airlock to ensure it has liquid and is functioning correctly.
Bottling Bucket and Wand: Preparing for the Final Stage
Once fermentation is complete, the beer needs to be transferred to bottles for carbonation and aging. This is where the bottling bucket and bottling wand come into play.
The bottling bucket is a food-grade bucket with a spigot near the bottom. The spigot allows for easy filling of bottles without disturbing the sediment (trub) that has settled at the bottom of the fermentation vessel.
The bottling wand is a small tube that attaches to the spigot of the bottling bucket. It has a spring-loaded valve at the bottom. When pressed against the bottom of a bottle, it allows beer to flow in. This minimizes splashing and oxidation during bottling.
Using a bottling bucket and wand provides a controlled and sanitary way to package your beer.
Bottles and Caps: The Vessels of Enjoyment
The choice of bottles comes down to glass or PET plastic.
Glass bottles are reusable, readily available, and offer excellent protection against oxygen permeation. Standard 12-ounce bottles are the most common. These are easily capped with a bottle capper. You can also find larger 22-ounce "bomber" bottles.
PET plastic bottles are lighter and shatter-resistant. These are a good option if you are concerned about breakage or plan to transport your beer frequently. However, they are more permeable to oxygen than glass.
Regardless of the bottle type, bottle caps are essential for sealing your beer and creating carbonation. Use new, unused bottle caps for each batch to ensure a proper seal. A bottle capper is required to crimp the caps onto the bottles.
Cleaning and Sanitation: The Unsung Heroes
Cleaning removes visible dirt and grime. Sanitation eliminates microorganisms that can spoil your beer. Both are absolutely critical for successful homebrewing.
A variety of cleaning agents are available, including brewing-specific cleaners and dish soap (ensure it’s thoroughly rinsed). For sanitation, common options include:
-
Star San: A popular no-rinse sanitizer.
-
Idophor: Requires a short contact time.
-
Bleach: Effective, but requires careful rinsing to avoid off-flavors.
In addition to sanitizers, you’ll need brushes of various sizes to clean your equipment. A carboy brush is particularly useful for cleaning the inside of fermentation vessels. Always follow the manufacturer’s instructions for cleaning and sanitizing agents.
Optional Equipment: Leveling Up Your Brew
While the above equipment is essential, a few optional items can significantly improve your brewing experience.
A wort chiller is a device used to rapidly cool wort after boiling. This reduces the risk of contamination and improves the clarity of the final product. Immersion chillers (placed directly in the wort) and counterflow chillers (wort flows through a tube surrounded by cold water) are two common types.
Starter Kit vs. Individual Components: Making the Right Choice
Purchasing a homebrewing starter kit can be an excellent option for beginners. These kits typically include all the essential equipment you need to brew your first batch of beer.
The advantage of a kit is convenience and cost savings. Kits often offer a discounted price compared to buying each item separately. They also provide a guided introduction to the brewing process.
Alternatively, you can purchase individual components. This allows you to customize your setup and choose higher-quality equipment from the start.
This approach may be more expensive initially. However, it can be a worthwhile investment if you plan to continue homebrewing for the long term.
Ultimately, the decision depends on your budget, brewing goals, and level of commitment. Regardless of your approach, investing in quality equipment will set you up for success and enjoyment in your homebrewing journey.
Homebrewing empowers you to bring these visions to life, creating beers that are truly one-of-a-kind.
While the initial investment in equipment might seem daunting, homebrewing can actually be a cost-effective way to enjoy high-quality beer.
Once you have your basic setup, the cost per bottle is significantly lower than purchasing comparable craft beers from a store.
Moreover, you have complete control over the entire brewing process. That journey begins with assembling the necessary tools to turn your brewing dreams into a reality.
Now equipped to embark on your brewing journey, it’s time to shift our focus to the heart of every great beer: the ingredients. Understanding the role of each component – water, malt, hops, and yeast – is paramount to crafting the perfect brew.
The Ingredient List: Brewing Basics Unveiled
At its core, beer is a remarkably simple beverage, crafted from just four essential ingredients: water, malt, hops, and yeast. Yet, within this simplicity lies a world of complexity. The interplay of these ingredients, their individual characteristics, and the brewer’s skill in combining them, determines the final flavor profile of the beer. Choosing quality ingredients is the first step toward brewing excellence.
Water: The Unsung Hero
Often overlooked, water constitutes the vast majority of beer. Its quality and mineral composition have a profound impact on the final product. Different water profiles are suited for different styles of beer.
For example, hard water (high in mineral content) is well-suited for brewing dark ales, while soft water is ideal for pilsners.
Water Quality Considerations
Tap water often contains chlorine or chloramine, which can produce undesirable flavors in beer. It’s crucial to filter your water to remove these compounds. Activated carbon filters are effective for this purpose.
pH and Mineral Content
pH is a measure of acidity or alkalinity. The ideal pH for brewing water typically falls between 5.2 and 5.6 during the mashing process. Mineral content, particularly calcium, magnesium, and bicarbonates, can influence the mash pH and the flavor of the beer. Consider using brewing salts to adjust the mineral content of your water to match the desired beer style.
Malt: The Soul of Beer
Malted barley, or simply malt, provides the sugars that yeast ferment into alcohol and carbon dioxide. It also contributes significantly to the beer’s color, flavor, and body.
Base Malts
These malts form the foundation of the grain bill and provide the majority of the fermentable sugars. Pale malt, Pilsner malt, and Vienna malt are common examples. They contribute subtle, grainy flavors.
Specialty Malts
Specialty malts are kilned or roasted to varying degrees, imparting a wide range of colors and flavors. Caramel malts contribute sweetness and toffee-like notes. Chocolate and roasted barley provide dark, roasty flavors and colors, often found in stouts and porters. Understanding these malts allows brewers to craft complex and nuanced beers.
Hops: Bitterness, Aroma, and Beyond
Hops are the flowers of the hop plant, and they contribute bitterness, aroma, and flavor to beer. They also act as a natural preservative. The bitterness comes from alpha acids, which are isomerized during the boil.
Bittering Hops
These hops have a high alpha acid content and are added early in the boil to impart bitterness. Common examples include Magnum, Northern Brewer, and Chinook.
Aroma Hops
Added later in the boil or during dry-hopping (adding hops after fermentation), aroma hops contribute floral, citrusy, fruity, or spicy aromas. Cascade, Citra, and Galaxy are popular choices. The timing of hop additions is crucial for maximizing their aromatic potential.
Yeast: The Alchemist
Yeast is a single-celled microorganism responsible for fermentation, the process of converting sugars into alcohol and carbon dioxide. Different yeast strains produce different flavor compounds, greatly influencing the final beer character.
Ale Yeasts
Ale yeasts ferment at warmer temperatures (60-75°F) and typically produce fruity esters and other complex flavors. Examples include Saccharomyces cerevisiae.
Lager Yeasts
Lager yeasts ferment at cooler temperatures (45-55°F) and produce cleaner, crisper beers. Examples include Saccharomyces pastorianus.
Wild Yeasts
Wild yeasts, such as Brettanomyces, can contribute unique, funky, and sour flavors. They are often used in sour beers and other experimental styles. Working with wild yeasts requires careful sanitation to prevent contamination of other batches.
Choosing the right yeast strain is just as important as selecting the right malt and hops. It’s the yeast that ultimately brings all the ingredients together to create the final beer.
The interplay of these ingredients, their individual characteristics, and the brewer’s skill in combining them, determines the final flavor profile of the beer. Choosing quality ingredients is the first step toward brewing excellence. But even the finest ingredients are useless without the proper process. That’s where the art and science of brewing come together, transforming simple components into something extraordinary.
The Brewing Process: A Step-by-Step Guide
The brewing process, while seemingly complex at first, is a series of well-defined steps designed to extract sugars from grain, impart flavor and aroma, sanitize the liquid, and allow yeast to ferment those sugars into alcohol and carbon dioxide. Understanding each step is crucial for consistently producing quality beer. Let’s break down the process into manageable chunks.
Mashing: Unlocking the Sugars
Mashing is the crucial first step where the starches within the milled grains are converted into fermentable sugars. These sugars are what the yeast will later consume to create alcohol and CO2. This conversion is achieved by steeping the grains in hot water at specific temperatures.
Temperature control is paramount during the mash. Different enzymes activate at different temperatures, breaking down the starches in distinct ways. A typical mash schedule involves holding the mash at around 148-158°F (64-70°C) for 60-90 minutes.
Mash duration also plays a role. Longer mash times generally result in a more complete conversion of starches to sugars, leading to a higher alcohol content.
Lautering: Separating the Wort
Lautering is the process of separating the sugary liquid, now called wort, from the spent grains. This is typically done in two stages: mashout and sparging.
Mashout involves raising the temperature of the mash to around 170°F (77°C) to stop enzymatic activity and make the wort less viscous.
Sparging is the process of rinsing the grains with hot water (around 170°F) to extract any remaining sugars. This ensures that you’re getting the most out of your grains.
Boiling: Flavor, Sanitization, and More
The wort is then transferred to a brew kettle and boiled vigorously for 60-90 minutes. This step serves several crucial purposes:
- Sanitization: The high heat kills any unwanted microorganisms that may have survived the mashing process.
- Hop Addition: Hops are added during the boil to impart bitterness, aroma, and flavor. The timing of hop additions is crucial. Bittering hops are typically added early in the boil for maximum isomerization of alpha acids (the source of bitterness). Aroma hops are added later in the boil or even after the boil (whirlpool addition) to preserve their delicate aromas.
- Protein Coagulation: The boil helps to coagulate proteins, which can contribute to haze in the finished beer.
- Concentration: The boil evaporates excess water, concentrating the wort and increasing the specific gravity (sugar content).
Cooling: Preparing for Fermentation
After the boil, the wort needs to be cooled down to fermentation temperature as quickly as possible. This minimizes the risk of infection by unwanted bacteria or wild yeasts.
A wort chiller is highly recommended for this step, as it can rapidly cool the wort in 20-30 minutes. Alternatively, the brew kettle can be placed in an ice bath, but this method is much slower and carries a higher risk of contamination.
Fermentation: The Yeast’s Turn
Once the wort is cooled, it’s time to pitch the yeast. Fermentation is the process where yeast consumes the sugars in the wort and produces alcohol, carbon dioxide, and a variety of flavor compounds.
Temperature control is critical during fermentation. Different yeast strains have different optimal fermentation temperatures. Ale yeasts typically ferment at warmer temperatures (60-72°F/16-22°C), while lager yeasts ferment at cooler temperatures (48-58°F/9-14°C). Maintaining the correct temperature is essential for producing the desired flavor profile and preventing off-flavors.
Monitoring fermentation progress is also important. This can be done by taking hydrometer readings to track the specific gravity of the wort. As the yeast consumes sugars, the specific gravity will decrease. Fermentation is typically complete when the specific gravity stabilizes for several days.
Bottling and Conditioning: Patience is a Virtue
After weeks of careful brewing, mashing, boiling, and fermenting, the final stretch of the homebrewing journey arrives: bottling and conditioning. This stage, often underestimated, is where your beer develops its signature carbonation and subtle complexities, transforming it from a flat, young brew into a polished, enjoyable beverage. While the temptation to crack open a bottle immediately is strong, patience during this phase is paramount, as it directly impacts the final quality and safety of your beer.
Priming for Perfection: Calculating Carbonation
Bottling introduces a crucial element: priming sugar. This small addition of fermentable sugar provides the remaining yeast with a final meal, producing the carbon dioxide necessary for a properly carbonated beer. However, calculating the correct amount of priming sugar is essential. Too little, and your beer will be flat; too much, and you risk over-carbonation, which can lead to bottle bombs.
Several online calculators and charts are available to assist with this calculation. These tools typically require you to input the volume of beer you’re bottling and the desired carbonation level, usually measured in volumes of CO2. Different beer styles call for different carbonation levels. For example, a British bitter will require less carbonation than a Belgian Saison.
Common priming sugars include dextrose (corn sugar), sucrose (table sugar), and dry malt extract (DME). Dextrose is often favored for its consistent fermentability. Once you’ve calculated the correct amount, dissolve the priming sugar in a small amount of boiling water to sanitize it and ensure even distribution within the bottling bucket.
The Sacred Ritual of Sanitization
Sanitation is non-negotiable during bottling. Every surface that comes into contact with your beer after fermentation—bottles, bottling bucket, bottling wand, bottle caps—must be meticulously sanitized. Even a small amount of bacteria or wild yeast can lead to off-flavors, cloudiness, or even render your beer undrinkable.
Use a no-rinse sanitizer, such as Star San or Saniclean, according to the manufacturer’s instructions. Ensure that the sanitizer makes contact with all interior surfaces of the bottles. A bottle rinser can be a helpful tool for this process. Submerge your bottling wand and bottle caps in the sanitizing solution for the recommended contact time.
Remember, sanitization is not the same as sterilization. We are aiming to reduce the microbial load to a safe level, not eliminate all microorganisms entirely.
Conditioning: Time and Temperature
Once your bottles are filled and capped, the conditioning process begins. This is where the beer undergoes further maturation, allowing the yeast to consume the priming sugar and produce carbon dioxide. The CO2 dissolves into the beer, creating the desired level of carbonation. Simultaneously, the beer’s flavors will mellow and meld together, creating a more refined and balanced profile.
The ideal temperature for bottle conditioning is typically between 65-70°F (18-21°C). Store your bottles upright in a dark, temperature-stable location. Avoid direct sunlight, as UV light can cause skunking (a light-struck off-flavor).
The conditioning time varies depending on the beer style and the amount of priming sugar used. Generally, allow at least two to three weeks for adequate carbonation and flavor development. Some stronger beers, particularly those with higher alcohol content, may benefit from longer conditioning periods, even months. Periodically sample a bottle to assess carbonation and flavor.
Bottle Bombs: A Word of Caution
Over-priming can lead to a dangerous situation known as "bottle bombs." If too much priming sugar is added, or if fermentation was not fully complete before bottling, excessive pressure can build up inside the bottles. This can cause the bottles to shatter, sending glass shards flying.
Always use accurate measurements when calculating priming sugar. Ensure fermentation is complete by taking hydrometer readings over several days to confirm a stable final gravity. If you suspect over-carbonation, refrigerate the bottles to slow down yeast activity and carefully vent them by slightly loosening the caps. Wear eye protection and gloves when handling potentially over-carbonated bottles.
The Patience Payoff
Bottling and conditioning are the final steps in the brewing process. While it requires a bit more patience, the reward is well worth the wait. A properly carbonated, well-conditioned beer is a testament to your brewing skills and a delicious reward for your hard work. So, resist the urge to rush this stage and allow your beer to reach its full potential.
Priming complete, the bottles are sealed, and the waiting game begins. But what happens if, after all that anticipation, your beer doesn’t taste quite right? Or worse, fermentation seems to have ground to a halt? Fear not, for even seasoned brewers encounter hiccups along the way. The key is understanding common problems and learning how to diagnose and address them.
Troubleshooting and Common Mistakes: Learning from Experience
Homebrewing, while rewarding, isn’t without its challenges. Beginner brewers often face similar hurdles, from unexpected off-flavors to fermentation issues and dreaded infections. The good news is that most of these problems are preventable with careful attention to detail and a healthy dose of troubleshooting knowledge.
Mistakes are inevitable; viewing them as learning opportunities is crucial. This section will explore common pitfalls, providing practical advice to help you navigate the occasionally turbulent waters of homebrewing and elevate your brewing skills.
Decoding Off-Flavors: A Brewer’s Sensory Guide
Off-flavors are the bane of any brewer’s existence. Identifying the culprit is the first step towards resolving the issue.
Is it buttery and slick? You might be detecting diacetyl, often described as butterscotch or popcorn. This compound is a natural byproduct of fermentation but is usually reabsorbed by the yeast. High fermentation temperatures, insufficient yeast health, or premature racking can lead to elevated diacetyl levels.
Does your beer have a hot, solvent-like character? Fusel alcohols are likely to blame. These higher alcohols are produced during fermentation, especially at high temperatures, or when the yeast is stressed due to under-pitching or nutrient deficiencies.
Is there a band-aid or medicinal aroma? Chlorophenols, created by the interaction of chlorine with phenols present in the beer, could be the source. Ensure you’re using chlorine-free water and proper sanitation techniques.
Does it taste papery or like cardboard? This indicates oxidation, which can occur if your beer is exposed to oxygen after fermentation. Minimize splashing during transfers and ensure your equipment is properly sealed.
Recognizing and Preventing Infections: Aseptic Practices
Infections are every homebrewer’s nightmare, introducing unwanted bacteria or wild yeast that can ruin an entire batch. Prevention is paramount, and meticulous sanitation is non-negotiable.
Identifying Infections
Visual cues can often indicate an infection. Look for:
- Unusual pellicle formation (a film on the beer’s surface).
- Unpleasant aromas (sour, vinegary, or barnyard-like).
- Excessive sediment in the bottle.
Preventative Measures
- Sanitize everything: Before they come into contact with your wort or beer, ensure every piece of equipment is thoroughly cleaned and sanitized. Use a reliable sanitizer like Star San or Iodophor, following the manufacturer’s instructions.
- Boil your wort: The boil is critical for sanitizing the wort, killing most microorganisms.
- Proper storage: Store your ingredients in a cool, dry place to prevent contamination.
Reviving Stalled Fermentation: Troubleshooting Tips
A stalled fermentation can be frustrating, leaving you with a sweet, under-attenuated beer. Before panicking, consider these troubleshooting steps:
- Check the temperature: Yeast thrives within a specific temperature range. Ensure your fermentation is happening within that range. Use a thermometer to verify the temperature and adjust accordingly.
- Re-pitch yeast: If fermentation has stalled for an extended period, the yeast may have become inactive. Pitching a fresh packet of yeast can often restart the process. Consider making a yeast starter to ensure the yeast is healthy and active before pitching.
- Gently rouse the yeast: Sometimes, the yeast simply needs a bit of encouragement. Gently swirling the fermentation vessel can help to re-suspend the yeast and promote activity. Avoid introducing oxygen while doing this.
- Ensure adequate nutrient levels: Yeast needs nutrients to thrive. If you suspect a nutrient deficiency, consider adding yeast nutrient to the fermenter.
Resources for Continued Learning
Homebrewing is a continuous learning process. Don’t hesitate to seek guidance from experienced brewers and reliable resources.
- Books: “The Complete Joy of Homebrewing” by Charlie Papazian and "How to Brew" by John Palmer are considered essential reading for homebrewers.
- Websites: Websites like BrewersFriend.com, HomebrewTalk.com, and American Homebrewers Association (homebrewersassociation.org) provide a wealth of information, recipes, and troubleshooting advice.
- Forums: Online forums are a great place to connect with other homebrewers, ask questions, and share experiences.
- Local Homebrew Clubs: Joining a local homebrew club can provide valuable hands-on experience and access to a community of knowledgeable brewers.
Frequently Asked Questions: Understanding MVU Calculation
Here are some common questions to help you better understand the concept of MVU calculation.
What exactly is an MVU?
MVU stands for Minimum Variance Unbiased estimator. It’s the best unbiased estimator because it has the smallest possible variance among all unbiased estimators for a given parameter. Finding a good mvu calculation example is key to understanding the concept.
Why is finding an MVU important?
Finding an MVU is important because it provides the most precise estimate of a population parameter, given that the estimator is unbiased. In practice, you always want the most accurate estimate. A well-crafted mvu calculation example shows its benefits.
How do I know if an estimator is an MVU?
You can prove an estimator is an MVU using theorems like the Lehmann-Scheffé Theorem or the Rao-Blackwell Theorem. These theorems provide conditions that, if met, guarantee that an estimator is the Minimum Variance Unbiased estimator. Referencing an mvu calculation example can help understand how these theorems are applied.
What happens if I can’t find an MVU?
If an MVU cannot be found, you might consider looking for other estimators that are "best" in some sense, even if they are not strictly MVU. You may need to relax the unbiasedness constraint or focus on minimizing the mean squared error (MSE) instead of just the variance. Even without an MVU, the process of exploring the mvu calculation example is valuable.
Alright, so now you have a clearer picture of the mvu calculation example. Go ahead and experiment with different scenarios and really nail down that minimum viable utility for your next project. Happy calculating!